Black fabric grow bags have become a favorite among gardeners for their lightweight design, excellent drainage, and root-air pruning capabilities. Yet concerns have emerged about potential microplastic shedding and chemical leaching from recycled plastic materials. In this post, we’ll explore the safety of these bags, examine what materials and certifications to look for, and offer recommendations for reputable brands and safe alternatives—including natural fiber options and hard plastic pots.
Microplastics, Materials, & Safer Alternatives
Many fabric grow bags are made of recycled plastics, such as polypropylene (PP) or polyethylene terephthalate (PET). Their fibrous, breathable construction can improve root growth but may also shed tiny plastic particles over time. This microplastic release is primarily a concern because the bags degrade under UV exposure and regular watering. Shedding is much more of a concern with fibrous versus solid plastics.
While research is still ongoing, early studies suggest that virgin plastics may be safer than recycled plastics. Solid plastics are also preferable to fibrous plastics simply due to the fact that a solid is less likely to break down with handling. Consider these strategies:
Invest in Quality: BPA-free virgin plastics that are solid may cost a few dollars more, but last longer in addition to being potentially safer for health and environment. Choosing these more durable plastics also reduces overall waste.
Gentle Handling: If you’re already using these bags and can’t replace them right away, minimizing abrasion during cleaning or moving can lessen fiber shedding.
Containment Solutions: It may be possible to reduce shedding from your grow bags to surrounding soil by placing your grow bags into a secondary container.
Material Safety and Chemical Leaching
Beyond the physical issue of microplastics, many gardeners wonder if any chemicals might leach from fabric grow bags into the soil. The safety of a plastic product largely depends on the type of plastic used:
Food-Grade Plastics: Materials like high-density polyethylene (HDPE), low-density polyethylene (LDPE), polypropylene (PP), and PET are considered safe for food contact. These plastics are commonly used in food containers because they do not leach harmful chemicals under normal use.
Avoiding Certain Plastics: Products made from PVC or polycarbonate (often categorized as “#7” or “other”) may release toxins such as BPA or phthalates. Reputable grow bag manufacturers avoid these materials in favor of food-safe options.
Recycled Material Cautions: While recycling in general is aimed at reducing overall waste to help the environment, recycled materials must be carefully processed to avoid contaminants such as heavy metals. Additionally, bonding agents used to get recycled materials to hold their shape could be unsafe additives. Look for manufacturers who verify that their recycled content meets stringent standards.
Many trusted brands state that their products are BPA-free, phthalate-free, and use either virgin or properly processed recycled plastic. This transparency is crucial for ensuring that the products remain inert in your garden. Research companies to find out whether they adhere to the standards they claim to in their marketing.
Certifications and Transparency
When shopping for grow bags, certain certifications can provide extra peace of mind:
Global Recycled Standard (GRS): This certification verifies that recycled content is processed under strict criteria, ensuring the material is free from harmful contaminants.
Food-Grade Labels: Look for any indication that the plastic is “food safe” or that the product is tested to be BPA-free. While these labels don’t cover every potential issue, they do indicate that the manufacturer is aware of chemical safety concerns.
If a product’s labeling or website provides detailed information on the materials used, it’s a sign that the company may prioritize safety and quality.
Exploring Natural Fiber Grow Bags
For gardeners who prefer to avoid plastics entirely, natural fiber grow bags present an attractive alternative. Options include bags made from jute, burlap, or hemp. These materials are entirely biodegradable and completely free of synthetic microplastics.
Advantages of Natural Fiber Bags
Zero Microplastic Risk: Made entirely from plant fibers, these bags will not shed plastic particles.
Eco-Friendly: Being biodegradable, natural fiber bags can be composted after their useful life.
Breathable: Like synthetic fabric bags, natural fibers allow for excellent air and moisture movement, promoting healthy root growth.
Considerations When Using Natural Fiber Bags
Shorter Lifespan: Natural fibers decompose over time. You may need to replace them after one or two growing seasons.
Structural Strength: Natural fibers might not hold up as well with larger volumes of soil or frequent handling. They are often best used for smaller crops or as liners.
Availability: While options are growing, natural fiber bags are still somewhat niche. Some hybrid products combine natural fibers with a small percentage of plastic to extend lifespan while still reducing overall synthetic content. Read product descriptions carefully to make sure you know what you’re buying.
If you are environmentally cautious and willing to invest in a short-term solution that can be composted, natural fiber grow bags offer a compelling alternative.
Safer Hard Plastic Containers
For those who prefer the stability of a rigid container over a fabric grow bag, hard plastic pots are another safer option—provided you choose the right material. Hard containers made from food-grade plastics such as HDPE and PP are widely used in food storage and are less prone to microplastic shedding because they lack the fibrous structure of fabric bags.
Recommendations for Hard Plastic Pots
EarthBox® Planter: The EarthBox system is a popular self-watering planter designed for growing vegetables. These containers are made from UV-stable, BPA-free plastic, ensuring safety over many seasons. EarthBox products have a longstanding reputation in both home and school gardens for their durability and safety.
Air-Pot® Containers: Air-Pot containers feature a unique design with holes that encourage air-pruning of roots, similar to fabric grow bags. Made from recycled HDPE, Air-Pots are designed for longevity. HDPE is a proven, food-safe plastic used in everyday items like milk jugs, and its use in Air-Pots reinforces the safety and durability of the product.
High-Quality Nursery Pots: Many traditional nursery pots are constructed from polypropylene. Trusted brands such as Bloem and Akro-Mils offer durable, food-grade plastic pots that can be used safely for edibles. These are often available in various sizes, including repurposed food-grade 5-gallon buckets (after ensuring they have not previously contained harmful substances).
Restaurant discards: It is often possible to collect food-safe plastic vessels from local restaurants. Many receive large quantities of food in BPA free containers that they simply discard after use. As these are designed to be food safe, they can provide a cheap or free alternative to purchasing garden vessels. In the Chicagoland area, Portillo’s restaurant sells pickle buckets for $2 as part of an ongoing heart health fundraiser. Options like this may exist in any community with restaurants. It can’t hurt to stop into an establishment and ask!
When choosing any hard plastic container, check for clear labels indicating food-grade material and BPA-free status. This ensures that your container remains inert and safe for growing edibles.
Final Thoughts
While black plastic grow bags are accessible and affordable, they come with potential health risks to the environment and to the health of the person eating food produced in them. These risks come both from the potential for microplastic shedding as well as chemical leaching. Avoiding use of plastics in the garden altogether is best practice, but not always affordable. Solid, virgin plastics that are labeled food safe are the safest plastics to use in the garden.
Happy gardening—and may your harvests be as bountiful as they are safe!
Happy Gardening!
By following the Deep Roots Project’s transformational gardening methods through the seasons, you will create a thriving, nutrient-rich garden that supports both your plants and the soil. See the full list of our Grow Your Own Food blog posts. Each post is assigned ”tags” which are under the post title.
Deep Roots Supports Gardeners
We provide our gardeners with the best products for success – like cedar raised beds, microbe-rich compost and microbe-rich worm castings. Check our online store. Always talk to our customer support team before placing your order online. If you need help or have a question contact us at support[at]deep-roots-project.org and 708-655-5299.
Deep Roots Online Store
See our online store for details about prices, ordering and delivery of raised beds, planter boxes, microbe-rich compost, worm castings, leaf mulch and more. We don’t sell traditional soil, since we use 100% compost as our growing medium. Our online store has 2 sections – (1) raised beds and planter boxes and (2) compost, worm castings, fertilizer.
Please contact our customer support team before placing an order online so we can assist you with the details and answer your gardening questions. You can pay by credit card in the store or by check.
Please leave your cell phone number when you sign up for our eNewsletter, if you want text message announcements now and then.
Donations help us provide organic kitchen gardening education to individuals, organizations, and entire communities. Thank you in advance for contributing to our community and for sharing our website and blog with friends and family.
